Is Sominex Stronger Than Nytol? (2025 UK Guide)

Quick Takeaways

• Sominex and Nytol are both over-the-counter sleep aids sold in the UK, but they use different active ingredients.

• Sominex contains promethazine hydrochloride, which tends to be stronger and longer-lasting than Nytol's diphenhydramine hydrochloride.

• Nytol may suit those with milder or more occasional sleep issues who want a shorter-acting effect.

• Both products should only be used short-term, and prolonged use is not recommended without medical advice.

Finding an effective sleep aid can be difficult, especially when faced with options like Sominex and Nytol at the pharmacy. Both are well-known names across the UK, but they work differently, and their effects can vary significantly from person to person.

This guide explores the key differences, strengths, and considerations when choosing between Sominex and Nytol.

Sominex vs Nytol – Which Sleep Aid Works Best?

Sominex and Nytol are classified as "first-generation" antihistamines. Although originally developed for allergy relief, they cause drowsiness as a side effect, which is now harnessed to help people fall asleep.

• Sominex: Contains promethazine hydrochloride (20mg per tablet)

• Nytol Original: Contains diphenhydramine hydrochloride (25mg per tablet)

• Nytol One-A-Night: A higher dose of diphenhydramine (50mg per tablet)

Both products are intended for short-term relief of occasional sleeplessness.

How Does Sominex Work?

Sominex works by blocking histamine receptors in the brain. Histamine promotes wakefulness, so blocking its action leads to drowsiness and sedation.

• Onset: Usually within 30–60 minutes

• Duration: Effects can last up to 12 hours, sometimes longer

• Best for: People with more persistent or severe short-term sleep problems

Promethazine also crosses the blood-brain barrier quite effectively, which contributes to its strong sedative action.

How Does Nytol Work?

Nytol operates similarly but uses a different chemical — diphenhydramine. Like promethazine, it blocks histamine receptors, but it also has some anticholinergic properties, which can intensify drowsiness.

• Onset: Typically within 20–60 minutes

• Duration: Effects tend to last 4–6 hours, though this can vary

• Best for: People who struggle to fall asleep but do not need as long-lasting sedation

Nytol comes in two main versions:

• Nytol Original: 25mg diphenhydramine

• Nytol One-A-Night: 50mg diphenhydramine for a stronger single-dose effect

Head-to-Head: Sominex vs Nytol

Feature	Sominex	Nytol
Active Ingredient	Promethazine Hydrochloride	Diphenhydramine Hydrochloride
Usual Dose	20mg	25mg or 50mg (One-A-Night)
Onset of Action	30-60 minutes	20-60 minutes
Duration	Up to 12 hours	4-6 hours
Best for	Longer sleep support	Short-term sleep onset help
Common Side Effects	Drowsiness, dry mouth, dizziness	Drowsiness, dry mouth, grogginess

Is Sominex Stronger Than Nytol?

In short: yes, Sominex is generally considered stronger than Nytol for most people.

• Pharmacological strength: Promethazine has a broader sedative effect and tends to linger in the body longer.

• Half-life: Promethazine’s half-life is approximately 10–19 hours, compared to diphenhydramine’s 4–9 hours【source: British National Formulary】.

• Subjective experience: Many users report deeper sedation and more difficulty waking up after taking Sominex compared to Nytol.

However, "stronger" doesn't automatically mean "better." Some people prefer the shorter action of Nytol to avoid morning grogginess.

Veranite - All Natural Sleep Supplement

Buy Now

Veranite: A Natural Alternative to Strong Sleeping Pills

Veranite is a natural sleep aid developed by a leading UK sleep and anxiety specialist. Unlike stronger synthetic sleep tablets, Veranite works by supporting the body’s natural rhythms rather than forcing sedation. It combines ingredients like Coffea, which helps calm a racing mind, Daphne Indica to ease emotional restlessness, Kali Phos to support the nervous system, and Passiflora to promote relaxation.

Instead of knocking the body into sleep, Veranite gently encourages a smoother transition into rest, aiming to reduce overstimulation and help improve sleep quality over time. It is non-habit forming and designed for those who want a softer, more natural approach to sleep without the grogginess often associated with stronger sleep medications.

Which One Is Better for Severe Insomnia?

Neither Sominex nor Nytol is intended for long-term management of chronic insomnia.

• Sominex may suit cases of acute, severe sleeplessness, such as after a stressful life event.

• Nytol might be preferred if the problem is falling asleep rather than staying asleep.

Important: Chronic insomnia typically requires medical assessment and non-drug interventions such as Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for Insomnia (CBT-I)

Safety Warnings and Precautions

Both Sominex and Nytol carry safety risks, especially if misused.

• Next-day drowsiness: Common with both products, more so with Sominex

• Falls and accidents: Especially in older adults

• Interaction with alcohol: Should be strictly avoided

• Tolerance and dependency: Risk increases with prolonged use

The NHS advises that antihistamine sleeping tablets should only be used for short periods (usually no more than a few days at a time).

Anyone with underlying health conditions, including glaucoma, breathing problems, or prostate issues, should seek medical advice before use.

Natural Alternatives to Sominex and Nytol

Beyond Veranite, there are several gentler options worth exploring:

• Magnesium supplements: Help regulate sleep patterns

• Valerian root: Linked to improved sleep onset and quality

• Chamomile tea: Traditional herbal remedy for relaxation

• Melatonin supplements: Available on private prescription in the UK

• Good sleep hygiene: Dark, quiet rooms; consistent sleep schedules; avoiding screens before bed

Verdict: Sominex vs Nytol – Which Is the Right Choice?

• For stronger, longer sedation: Sominex tends to outperform Nytol.

• For help falling asleep without heavy sedation: Nytol Original or Nytol One-A-Night might be better.

• For a natural and sustainable option: Veranite offers an alternative without harsh sedation.

Ultimately, choice depends on individual needs, sensitivity to medication, and the nature of the sleep difficulty.

Conclusion: Finding the Right Sleep Aid Safely

Choosing between Sominex and Nytol depends on the severity and type of sleep issue at hand. Sominex offers stronger sedation, better suited to more persistent sleeplessness, while Nytol may be preferred for milder or shorter-term problems.

For those concerned about over-reliance on medication, Veranite provides a natural, gentle way to support better sleep. Whichever route is taken, sleep aids should always be used responsibly, and if sleep problems persist, professional advice is essential.

---

FAQs About Sominex and Nytol

Can Sominex be taken every night?

No. It is meant for short-term use only, typically for a few days. Long-term use should be discussed with a healthcare provider.

How quickly does Nytol work?

Nytol usually starts working within 20 to 60 minutes after taking a tablet.

Is it safe to combine sleep aids?

Generally, no. Combining sedating antihistamines or mixing with alcohol or other sedatives can be dangerous.

Are Sominex and Nytol addictive?

While not classically addictive, tolerance can develop quickly, making the medication less effective and encouraging overuse.